Is there hope of peace with Ishmael?

Some Jews say never. The Torah in Parshas Lech Lecha tells the story of how Sarah, seeing that she was childless, asked Avraham to marry her servant woman Hagar. When Hagar became pregnant, the Torah says, “And Sarai dealt harshly with her, and she fled from before her face.” The Ramban comments:

“Our mother did transgress by this affliction, and Avraham also by his permitting her to do so. And so, G-d heard Hagar’s affliction and gave her a son who would be a wild man, to afflict the seed of Abraham and Sarah with all kinds of affliction.”

And the Rambam writes in his Letter to Yemen:

Remember, my co-religionists, that on account of the vast number of our sins, God has hurled us in the midst of this people, the Arabs, who have persecuted us severely, and passed baneful and discriminatory legislation against us, as Scripture has forewarned us, “Our enemies themselves shall judge us” (Devarim 32:31). Never did a nation molest, degrade, debase and hate us as much as they. Therefore when David, of blessed memory, inspired by the holy spirit, envisaged the future tribulations of Israel, he bewailed and lamented their lot only in the Kingdom of Ishmael, and prayed in their behalf, for their deliverance, as is implied in the verse, “Woe is me, that I sojourn with Meschech, that I dwell beside the tents of Kedar.” (Tehillim 120:5).

Citing these quotes, some Jews claim that there is no way to live in peace with Arabs.

But it’s a fact that Jews did live, relatively speaking, in peace in Arab lands for centuries. There were occasional attacks, to which the Rambam and Ramban may be referring. But for the most part, the Arab and Muslim world was kinder to the Jews than the European world. It must be that Middle Eastern Jews once knew the secrets of how to get along with Ishmael.

The following is from a 2013 interview with Rabbi Shlomo Zalman Sonnenfeld, grandson of Rabbi Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld and author of the biography Ha’ish Al Hachomah (translated into English as “Guardian of Jerusalem”). This interview originally appeared in Hebrew in Hamevaser magazine, 5 Shvat 5773.

“The principal issue at the heart of the conflict,” Rabbi Sonnenfeld begins, “is connected to the Ishmaelite mentality. In order to know how to deal with Arabs, one must understand the structure of their personality and their basic mentality. My grandfather, Maran Rabbi Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld, who was endowed above all with a sober view, knew the reality in our Holy Land a thousand times better than the Zionist leaders who had cast off the yoke and came from Europe to take control of life here. He was well acquainted with the Arab mentality through many years of familiarity and knew how to deal with them, and what one must beware of when dealing with them. By contrast, the Zionist leaders did not know ‘from which side to eat this dish.’ They spoke to the Arab as one European speaks to another, without noticing when they were treading on their sore points, and without knowing what they regarded as a compliment and what as disgrace and humiliation.

“And we are eating the bitter fruits to this very day. The result of the Zionist dealings with the Arabs and their failure to understand their mentality is tragic on an inconceivable scale. The foundation of the ordinary Ishmaelite’s personality is honor. Whether it is personal or national honor makes no difference: one who disparages the honor of an Ishmaelite makes an error for which there is no remedy for generations upon generations. The moment their honor is trampled and they are humiliated, they cast all restraint aside and act, in pursuit of revenge, even against their own interests. And this revenge does not end for generations—the Ishmaelite will pass on the trauma of his humiliation to his sons and grandsons until the end of all generations.”

Rabbi Sonnenfeld elaborates and illustrates the point:

“A simple example: after the Six-Day War, we had several more or less quiet years here with the Arabs. We could walk about in the streets of Arab cities without fear. This state of affairs continued for approximately twenty years. People who lived here imagined that this was indeed how it was meant to continue for generations—that the Arabs would remain submissive under the hand of the Jews—and they did not understand that the new generation that arose experienced only the humiliation and conquest without experiencing defeat in its war. This erupted in the form of the first and second intifadas, and brought about the entire terrible situation that continues to this very day, with no solution to this problem appearing on the horizon.

“One cannot injure Arab honor. Whoever does so is gambling with his life; and if an entire people humiliates Arab honor, that people will suffer the accursed vengeance of the Ishmaelites for generations. This basic fact was not known to the leaders of the Zionist Organization who came to the Land from Europe, and who thought that the rules operative there in Europe were valid here as well, in the Ishmaelite sphere.”

“Another matter underlying the Ishmaelite mentality is the blindness of vengeance and the intensity of hatred that he develops toward one who, in his view, humiliates him. In all of history there had never been such a concept as a ‘suicide terrorist.’ Throughout the awful Holocaust in Europe, there was not one German who killed himself in order to kill more Jews with him. The reason is that when hatred and emotion begin to ferment within an Ishmaelite, he first of all acts against his own basic interests. He destroys himself, his entire standing, and all his achievements—provided that he can take revenge against one who has humiliated his national or personal honor.

“If in those years it was necessary to stand and explain this basic fact to those who came from Europe and did not know the character of the Ishmaelite, today everyone living here in the region knows it. Living conditions in Gaza are extremely difficult and agitate them. In the rocket fire that led to the recent Operation Pillar of Defense, they knew full well that at some point patience would run out and they themselves would suffer as a result. But national honor and the desire for revenge stand above all else for them.

“Moreover: if among European or other peoples there is such a concept as ‘peace,’ and reconciliation is possible even after a state of war, it is different with the Ishmaelite. Once he has been harmed, there is no way in the world to reconcile him. There has never yet arisen anyone in the world who succeeded in reconciling a wounded and humiliated Ishmaelite.

“When a European speaks with an Arab about peace, he does not know that the Arab hears entirely different things from him. In practice, making peace or a peace agreement with an Arab is something impossible. In the long Arab history, there was never a reality in which they forgave one who fought them. If there were such agreements, they were in the category of a hudna, a temporary ceasefire, solely in preparation for a battle that would come one day, no matter when, for the Ishmaelite bears hatred for generations. These basic facts are known to every beginning Middle East scholar.

“The Arab, in principle, is not anti-Semitic. Fundamentally, he does not hate Jews. Over the generations we did not encounter Arab anti-Semitism. The Ishmaelite’s hatred arises from injury to his honor and from his humiliation. Then his emotions are aroused, and there is no end to his outburst of vengeance and hatred.

“Had the Zionists not trampled Arab honor and humiliated it, no hatred between Jews and Arabs would have developed. On the contrary, the Arabs themselves would have killed anyone who came to interfere with the Jews, for the flourishing of the Jews is their own flourishing. The Arab himself does not care who rules the country. After every attack, you can hear various Arabs saying to you, ‘Why do we need this terrorism? What do we gain from it?’—but all this is when reason is functioning; once they ignite the feeling of nationalism, the Arab is prepared to commit suicide, so long as he restores his humiliated honor.

“In those days there was no media and no way at all to incite the Arabs. The riots began on Fridays, after the masses heard the Mufti inciting them; then they lost control and began to run wild. Had they wisely preserved the Mufti’s honor, rather than angering and humiliating him, everything would have proceeded peacefully. Just as among us, the leftists are a negligible minority of the public, yet through various means they control the centers of power—the High Court of Justice and the media—and consequently control the entire public, so too the nationalists among the Arabs are a minority, but they control the centers of power and dictate the agenda of the entire Arab people.

“The Zionists, drunk with power and swollen with the pride of ‘כוחי ועוצם ידי’ — my own strength and the might of my hand, thought that it was possible to humiliate the Arabs, whom they regarded as primitive and backward. They simply did not know that if one harms and humiliates them, they are very dangerous.

“But my grandfather, Maran Rabbi Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld, of blessed memory, saw with his clear-sighted eyes what was going to happen. He saw how the Zionists were needlessly humiliating the Arabs and arousing their enduring enmity…

“The Zionist leader Ussishkin once met my grandfather, Maran Rabbi Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld, after the disturbances of 5689 (1929). Grandfather then said to him: King David said regarding the Ishmaelites, ‘אני שלום וכי אדבר המה למלחמה’ — I am for peace, but when I speak, they are for war. The culture of the Ishmaelites is bloodshed, and once hatred is ignited, they are prepared to spill blood without end. When they speak with you about peace, they mean to find a way to continue spilling blood.  We speak of peace because we do not want bloodshed, but they speak with you of peace and mean war. Ishmael’s central trait is ‘וישב במדבר ויהי רובה קשת’ — he dwelt in the wilderness, and became an archer. This is their inheritance received from Ishmael their father. Therefore, my grandfather, of holy and blessed memory, held that one must not arouse their enmity from the outset, for this enmity would have no end.

“My grandfather did not suffice with words, but began taking practical action in order to stop, in time, the fire that had begun to burn between the two peoples. He made every effort at his disposal to remove representation of the Jewish people from the hands of the Zionist Organization, which had taken control of the Yishuv, and transfer it to the members of the Old Yishuv, who constituted the majority, both in number and in substance, of the Jewish residents of the Land in those days—and at the same time, to make clear to the Arab people by every possible means that we had nothing whatsoever against them and wished to live with them peacefully, tranquilly, and as good neighbors, as we had lived with them until then, and that we had no aspiration whatsoever for self-rule or for a state of our own. It almost succeeded, until the terrible murder of Dr. Yaakov Yisrael De Haan, may Hashem avenge his blood, cut off this good initiative while it was still in its prime.

“These matters are known, but for the benefit of the readership among the younger generation, I shall elaborate in brief outline:

“Orthodox Jewry and the Old Yishuv found a great political leader, a first-rate diplomat named Dr. Yaakov Yisrael De Haan. He was born in Holland and received a religious-traditional education, but during his studies in the gymnasium he was swept into the current of assimilation and became an active member of the Social Democratic Party in Holland. Through his immense talents, at a young age he became one of Holland’s foremost jurists and a prominent, well-known figure in the corridors of government. After one of the Dutch royals made an antisemitic remark in his hearing, an upheaval took place within him. He returned to his roots and became a faithful Jew who observed Torah and mitzvos. In the course of his search for authentic Judaism, he joined the Mizrachi Organization in Holland and became one of its leading activists, but his restless soul sought something loftier, and thus he came to Eretz Yisrael. Upon arriving in the Land, he began studying life here, and thus he came to meet my grandfather, Maran Rabbi Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld, for the first time. This meeting wrought a complete transformation in his soul. At that meeting, my grandfather explained to him the political reality in full clarity, and he immediately grasped the simple logic and the clear-sighted perspective guiding the conduct of the Gedolei Yisrael. From then on, Dr. De Haan’s soul was bound to my grandfather’s soul. He visited him daily, and his words were for him as the Urim and Tumim.

“Dr. De Haan’s brilliant talents quickly made him the political secretary of the Edah HaChareidis and director of its foreign relations, and he soon plunged into the sea of work that stood waiting for a man like him. He formed connections in high places and succeeded in making himself well-liked by everyone. He associated with the leading figures of the English government, and as an outstanding Middle East scholar, he succeeded in forming diplomatic connections with the senior leaders of the Arab world, soon forging strong ties with them.

“Dr. De Haan’s standing was so great that he began to be seen as an alternative to the leaders of the Zionist Organization. This threw the members of the Zionist Organization into a panic. They had not expected that Orthodox Jewry would succeed in presenting such a clear alternative to their leadership.

“The most senior Arab leader in the Middle East region was Hussein, King of the Hejaz. Hussein, who had served as Sharif of Mecca, was appointed by the British as king of the Arabian Peninsula, while they divided the remaining lands of the Middle East among his sons. They appointed his eldest son, Faisal, king of Iraq; his son Ali as his heir in the Kingdom of Hejaz; and his younger son Abdullah as emir of Transjordan.

“When word spread of the visit of Hussein, King of the Hejaz, to his son Abdullah in Transjordan, Dr. De Haan hastened, through his extensive connections, to arrange a special meeting between the leaders of Orthodox Jewry and King Hussein and his sons. My grandfather, Maran Rabbi Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld, saw the holding of this visit as supremely important for saving the Jewish people for generations from the horrors entailed by the awakening of national passions and the hatred between the sides, and for this purpose he convened a rabbinical court and performed hataras nedarim — annulment of vows — regarding his undertaking not to leave Eretz Yisrael, an undertaking he had accepted upon himself on the very first day his feet trod upon it.

“The delegation included Maran Rabbi Chaim Sonnenfeld, Dr. De Haan, Rabbi Reuven Shlomo Jungreis, and Rabbi Avraham Chaim Naeh. The visit took place on 19 Adar 5684 (1924). The delegation submitted a memorandum stating that Orthodox Jewry, organized under the Agudas Yisrael Association, in which over a million members were registered, had granted no power of attorney to any other organization to speak in the name of the Jewish people.

“The meeting itself was very cordial. Also participating were the king’s son, Prince Ali, who was intended to inherit his father’s throne in the Kingdom of the Arabian Peninsula, and his son Abdullah, King of Jordan. The king awarded Grandfather, Maran Rabbi Chaim Sonnenfeld, the highest decoration of the Kingdom of the Arabian Peninsula.

“Dr. De Haan’s successful activity and the success of the meeting with the leader of the Arab world of those days threw the Zionists off balance. They raged with anger and could not bear to see how their plan to cause the Jews to abandon their religion and faith in an organized manner through the establishment of a state was crumbling in their hands. In response, they began pouring unprecedented scorn and hatred upon Orthodox Jewry, denouncing the entire Orthodox community as traitors and informers.

“The main focus of their anger was Dr. De Haan, who had succeeded, just as they had, in reaching all the corridors of power and understood the pathways of diplomacy, and had even been more successful than they were in his activity. At first, the Zionists thought that if they persecuted him, he would withdraw from his activities, and from then on they began personally persecuting him. They incited the students at the law school to create disturbances during his lectures, and threatened him that if he continued his political activity, he would be stripped of this position. Indeed, after some time Dr. De Haan was dismissed from his post, and his position as a correspondent on the staff of the Dutch newspaper was taken from him as well.

“When the personal humiliations did not help them at all, they decided to murder him. They had a green light publicly given by one of the leaders of Zionism (some say Ben-Zvi), and from then on it was all a matter of planning and execution. Dr. De Haan himself sensed that he was about to be murdered, but paid no heed to this and continued his activities. On 28 Sivan, Dr. De Haan was murdered. Three bullets pierced his heart, and he fell dead; with him, the entire campaign sank. Had Dr. De Haan continued his activity, Zionism would not have realized itself, there would not have been a state here—but the settlement in the Land would have flourished and prospered. Jews would have come to the Land in multitudes without any limitation; Arabs would have come to benefit from the economic prosperity; and the Land would have been among the most prosperous and successful countries in the world, without mutual bloodshed and without any particular enmity between Jews and Arabs. Today, this enmity threatens the peace of the entire world.

“Over the past several decades, the Zionist trend has changed. The situation today is that prime ministers regard it as an honor to shake the hands of our enemies. The reason for this is clear. The Zionists’ principal objective was to sever the Jewish people from the source from which they were hewn and turn them into a people like all other nations, Heaven forfend. In those days, the path to this was by igniting the fuse of Arab nationalism; today, after they have spiritually destroyed the overwhelming majority of the Jewish people, they are trying to realize that same objective through peace agreements with the Arabs.

“As stated, in those days, had we only wished to live together with them, it could have been done without any difficulty. But today—and this they do not know—there is no chance in the world of establishing genuine peace with the Arabs. For one who knows the Ishmaelite mentality knows that once the fuse has been lit, there is no way back. By the natural course of events, this situation has no solution. The Zionists want to make peace, but they have no one with whom to make it.”

In this interview, we see Rabbi S.Z. Sonnenfeld attempting to square his admiration for his grandfather with his current support of the state. He does this by arguing that it’s too late now to make peace, and the only option now is to have a strong Jewish state that fights the Arabs. He even manages to turn the tables and claim that Israeli peace efforts are not only doomed to failure but are part of their efforts to spiritually destroy the Jewish people (how that makes sense is anyone’s guess).

But his basic point about the Arab mentality contains more than a grain of truth. Alan Dershowitz has argued that that the Palestinians have been offered a state of their own many times, and have turned it down each time because “it was not so much that the Arabs wanted self-determination as that they did not want the Jews to have self-determination or sovereignty over the land the Jews themselves had cultivated and in which they were a majority.” (“The Ten Big Anti-Israel Lies,” p. 12) The Peel Commission found that “the sympathy of the Palestinian Arabs within their kinsmen in Syria had been plainly shown… Both people clung to the principle that Palestine was part of Syria and should never have been cut off from it.” (ibid. p. 9) “The Palestinian people have suffered more from the ill-advised decisions of their leaders than from the actions of Israel.” (ibid. p. 60) In light of Rabbi S.Z. Sonnenfeld’s characterization, “The moment their honor is trampled and they are humiliated, they cast all restraint aside and act, in pursuit of revenge, even against their own interests,” history becomes understandable.

But I believe Rabbi S.Z. is not correct in saying that there is no hope to turn things around, nor is he correct that the current Israeli leadership has changed tactics. Actually, the reason Arab violence continues is because the the Israelis have not changed. They insist that the state continue to be “Jewish and democratic.” Netanyahu blasts the Arab parties who just won an unprecedented number of seats, accusing them of “seeking the destruction of the Jewish state” and warning that they must not participate in or support a future government. The Arabs were denounced for their usual walkout during Hatikvah. (I wonder why the Haredi MK’s don’t walk out too…) As MK Yosef Jabareen, chairman of the Joint List, recited the words “I pledge” during his oath of allegiance, the moment that formally made him a sitting member, Ben-Gvir shouted at him: “Who is he pledging to? Hamas?!” And of course, the IDF continues to occupy more and more of the Gaza Strip (currently 65%), pushing Palestinians into the lowest-lying parts of Gaza, ensuring that as many people as possible are flooded by cold rainwater and sewage during the winter storms.

If Palestinians are treated respectfully, they will eventually join the growing Arab parties and partner with Jews in running the state. Jews can live safely in a state even if it is not a specifically Jewish state (and even if the anthem changes).

Leave a Reply